My Review: Susan Boyle’s CD “I Dreamed A Dream”

Susan Boyle Album Cover

Susan Boyle Album Cover

The juxtaposition was remarkable. We’re used to our musicians and actors being these young, stunning, darlings with out-of-this-world beauty and panache. And yet, this is as far from the case as we could have imagined. Susan Boyle’s singing was remarkable, while the looks, well, were also remarkable, but not in such a good way. The spectacular incongruity of it all made us all watch her, rapt attention paid to the voice referred to by some as angelic, leaving us with perhaps even an ambivalence about her looks, wanting the two to “match”.
Millions followed her rapid ascention to worldwide fame, almost overnight, watching one who might have been a hermetic recluse adjust to the constant, frenetic pace of the media and those who circle above, waiting impatiently to swoop down with their cameras, unafraid to badger and bewilder their prey until the inevitable breakdown.

After a long while, the day has come when Ms. Boyle has released an album of her own, allowing her international brood to no longer be limited to internet videos and random snippets from here and there.

I was looking forward to finding out whether her celebrity was merely due to her less than pretty looks, or whether her well-known set of pipes could hold their own and allow her to be a singer instead of the media freak she’s been until now.

My advise – stick to the videos. The voice we all absorbed in shocked amazement as we heard Les Miserables brought to life in the least likely of actors is still pretty good, but when the surprise and curiosity of her fame is gone, much of the luster and elation disappears, leaving you wanting more of the rare voice, less the empty celebrity. Don’t get me wrong; her voice is very nice, and the songs are all generally well-known, but the expectations for someone who wowed the entire world leave one very disappointed.


2 comments on “My Review: Susan Boyle’s CD “I Dreamed A Dream”

  1. Dorothy Gerstner says:

    I waited with so much anticipation for Susan Boyle’s CD and I was not disappointed. Her voice is so clear and beautiful and I look forward to her next CD. I have played this CD so many times and have enjoyed every minute listening to it. By the way, who cares what an artist looks like? Does it really matter? Her voice and soul are beautiful, and that is all that matters. I listen with my ears and not my eyes. There are too many beautiful singers who sound awful. They have looks but no talent. Is that better?

    • Avraham says:

      I certainly didn’t say that it mattered how an artist looked – quite the contrary, in fact. My intent when I first listened to the CD was to determine whether she garnered her acclaim because of her less-than-stellar looks or whether even if I listened “with my ears”, as you put it, I would still be equally enamored. As it turns out, the conclusion I reached was that it was more the surprise of the voice/appearance combination than the pure talent. To say she doesn’t have a lovely voice wouldn’t be true, but in my opinion, she doesn’t have nearly the amazing voice that some say she has.

      I guess we disagree about that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s